From oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca Tue Mar 30 08:06:52 2021 From: oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca (Mary O'Connor) Date: Tue, 30 Mar 2021 08:06:52 -0700 Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update In-Reply-To: <707123EE-7CB5-49A4-8C46-38D995F98C68@zoology.ubc.ca> References: <707123EE-7CB5-49A4-8C46-38D995F98C68@zoology.ubc.ca> Message-ID: <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> Hello everyone, Thanks for the feedback by the end of Feb, as requested! It took me a couple weeks to get it all wrapped up, and then I submitted our pre-submission request to PRSB, as required by the journal. The Reviews editor was way for a few weeks, hence the delay. I just heard back that we can submit our review, so I will do that today or tomorrow. That’s the update! So now, figures crossed and I’ll send around the submitted version when I’m done. Best, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com > On Feb 10, 2021, at 10:36 AM, Mary O'Connor wrote: > > Dear all, > > I hope you and yours are doing all right. I’m writing with the "Agenda paper", ready to submit and just need your final ‘OK’ or any minor feedback! > > Update: > > As you know, this has proceeded in fits and starts over the last few years. I thought we were done in summer 2019, but a few good points were raised around that time that required a bit more work on my part, and here we are. Last summer (2020) I presented this at ESA and around that time, got good and careful comments and contributions on the MS from our core writing team (Forest, Akira, Laura, Andy G). I have incorporated all those comments, and have also updated the manuscript a little bit since our original drafting (3 years ago!). > > I hope you like it! I’d like to submit it by the end of Feb to Proceedings of the Royal Society. Right now I’m simply asking for your ‘ok’. If there are revisions needed that can wait till we get reviews, I will happily take them and file them for that time; if things need to be done before we submit, I will do my best!. The ms hasn’t changed much since summer so if your read it then you have a good idea of where it is. If you haven’t read it in a few years, I suggest you do take a quick look. > > Finally, you will see that William Cheung has joined us as a co-author and on this email. William is a colleague at UBC and has been a contributor and co-author on the IBPES modelling scenarios and the scenarios chapter to which we refer in this paper, so I’m very grateful he has joined us and provided his comments on the ms as well. > > Action items (in summary): > > 1. Please confirm that you’re ok for me to submit this to PRSB > 2. Please send me your address or add it in a comment in the ms. > 3. OPTIONAL: help with figures if you are inspired > 4. OPTIONAL: minor edits for pre-submission, major edits for post-review > 5. OPTIONAL: Box 3 needs a little work, I think, and I wonder if one of you who originally drafted it could finalize it? > > A few loose ends on the figures remain to be tied up, which I will do while you review. If you have time AND see opportunities to improve figures, I welcome that help at this stage! (There were some issues I couldn’t resolve with the figures we had before, but if you miss them and would like help revise, we can discuss how to do that; it is possible). > > Best wishes, > > Mary > > > > > > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Dr. Mary O'Connor > Associate Professor, Department of Zoology > Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre > University of British Columbia > > ph: 604-827-5653 > oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca > oconnorlab.weebly.com > > _______________________________________________ > Bioprod mailing list > Bioprod at lists.lternet.edu > https://lists.lternet.edu/listinfo/bioprod -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From laura.ellen.dee at gmail.com Tue Mar 30 08:09:28 2021 From: laura.ellen.dee at gmail.com (Laura D.) Date: Tue, 30 Mar 2021 09:09:28 -0600 Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update In-Reply-To: <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> References: <707123EE-7CB5-49A4-8C46-38D995F98C68@zoology.ubc.ca> <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> Message-ID: Wonderful!!!!! Thanks Mary - fingers crossed! On Tue, Mar 30, 2021 at 9:07 AM Mary O'Connor wrote: > Hello everyone, > > Thanks for the feedback by the end of Feb, as requested! It took me a > couple weeks to get it all wrapped up, and then I submitted our > pre-submission request to PRSB, as required by the journal. The Reviews > editor was way for a few weeks, hence the delay. I just heard back that we > can submit our review, so I will do that today or tomorrow. That’s the > update! So now, figures crossed and I’ll send around the submitted version > when I’m done. > > Best, > > Mary > > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Dr. Mary O'Connor > Associate Professor, Department of Zoology > Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre > University of British Columbia > > ph: 604-827-5653 > oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca > oconnorlab.weebly.com > > > On Feb 10, 2021, at 10:36 AM, Mary O'Connor > wrote: > > Dear all, > > I hope you and yours are doing all right. I’m writing with the "Agenda > paper", ready to submit and just need your final ‘OK’ or any minor feedback! > > Update: > > As you know, this has proceeded in fits and starts over the last few > years. I thought we were done in summer 2019, but a few good points were > raised around that time that required a bit more work on my part, and here > we are. Last summer (2020) I presented this at ESA and around that time, > got good and careful comments and contributions on the MS from our core > writing team (Forest, Akira, Laura, Andy G). I have incorporated all those > comments, and have also updated the manuscript a little bit since our > original drafting (3 years ago!). > > I hope you like it! I’d like to submit it by the end of Feb to Proceedings > of the Royal Society. Right now I’m simply asking for your ‘ok’. If there > are revisions needed that can wait till we get reviews, I will happily take > them and file them for that time; if things need to be done before we > submit, I will do my best!. The ms hasn’t changed much since summer so if > your read it then you have a good idea of where it is. If you haven’t read > it in a few years, I suggest you do take a quick look. > > Finally, you will see that William Cheung has joined us as a co-author and > on this email. William is a colleague at UBC and has been a contributor and > co-author on the IBPES modelling scenarios and the scenarios chapter to > which we refer in this paper, so I’m very grateful he has joined us and > provided his comments on the ms as well. > > Action items (in summary): > > 1. Please confirm that you’re ok for me to submit this to PRSB > 2. Please send me your address or add it in a comment in the ms. > 3. OPTIONAL: help with figures if you are inspired > 4. OPTIONAL: minor edits for pre-submission, major edits for post-review > 5. OPTIONAL: Box 3 needs a little work, I think, and I wonder if one of > you who originally drafted it could finalize it? > > A few loose ends on the figures remain to be tied up, which I will do > while you review. If you have time AND see opportunities to improve > figures, I welcome that help at this stage! (There were some issues I > couldn’t resolve with the figures we had before, but if you miss them and > would like help revise, we can discuss how to do that; it is possible). > > Best wishes, > > Mary > > > > > > ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ > Dr. Mary O'Connor > Associate Professor, Department of Zoology > Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre > University of British Columbia > > ph: 604-827-5653 > oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca > oconnorlab.weebly.com > > _______________________________________________ > Bioprod mailing list > Bioprod at lists.lternet.edu > https://lists.lternet.edu/listinfo/bioprod > > > _______________________________________________ > Bioprod mailing list > Bioprod at lists.lternet.edu > https://lists.lternet.edu/listinfo/bioprod > -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From andrew.gonzalez at mcgill.ca Tue Mar 30 08:20:01 2021 From: andrew.gonzalez at mcgill.ca (Andrew Gonzalez, Prof.) Date: Tue, 30 Mar 2021 15:20:01 +0000 Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update In-Reply-To: <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> References: <707123EE-7CB5-49A4-8C46-38D995F98C68@zoology.ubc.ca>, <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> Message-ID: Hurrah! How great that PRSB will review it, Mary. Thank you for getting us to this point. Fingers crossed for smooth review! Andy ________________________________ From: Bioprod on behalf of Mary O'Connor Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2021 11:06 AM To: Forest Isbell Cc: William Cheung ; Michel Loreau ; bioprod at lternet.edu Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update Hello everyone, Thanks for the feedback by the end of Feb, as requested! It took me a couple weeks to get it all wrapped up, and then I submitted our pre-submission request to PRSB, as required by the journal. The Reviews editor was way for a few weeks, hence the delay. I just heard back that we can submit our review, so I will do that today or tomorrow. That’s the update! So now, figures crossed and I’ll send around the submitted version when I’m done. Best, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com On Feb 10, 2021, at 10:36 AM, Mary O'Connor > wrote: Dear all, I hope you and yours are doing all right. I’m writing with the "Agenda paper", ready to submit and just need your final ‘OK’ or any minor feedback! Update: As you know, this has proceeded in fits and starts over the last few years. I thought we were done in summer 2019, but a few good points were raised around that time that required a bit more work on my part, and here we are. Last summer (2020) I presented this at ESA and around that time, got good and careful comments and contributions on the MS from our core writing team (Forest, Akira, Laura, Andy G). I have incorporated all those comments, and have also updated the manuscript a little bit since our original drafting (3 years ago!). I hope you like it! I’d like to submit it by the end of Feb to Proceedings of the Royal Society. Right now I’m simply asking for your ‘ok’. If there are revisions needed that can wait till we get reviews, I will happily take them and file them for that time; if things need to be done before we submit, I will do my best!. The ms hasn’t changed much since summer so if your read it then you have a good idea of where it is. If you haven’t read it in a few years, I suggest you do take a quick look. Finally, you will see that William Cheung has joined us as a co-author and on this email. William is a colleague at UBC and has been a contributor and co-author on the IBPES modelling scenarios and the scenarios chapter to which we refer in this paper, so I’m very grateful he has joined us and provided his comments on the ms as well. Action items (in summary): 1. Please confirm that you’re ok for me to submit this to PRSB 2. Please send me your address or add it in a comment in the ms. 3. OPTIONAL: help with figures if you are inspired 4. OPTIONAL: minor edits for pre-submission, major edits for post-review 5. OPTIONAL: Box 3 needs a little work, I think, and I wonder if one of you who originally drafted it could finalize it? A few loose ends on the figures remain to be tied up, which I will do while you review. If you have time AND see opportunities to improve figures, I welcome that help at this stage! (There were some issues I couldn’t resolve with the figures we had before, but if you miss them and would like help revise, we can discuss how to do that; it is possible). Best wishes, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com _______________________________________________ Bioprod mailing list Bioprod at lists.lternet.edu https://lists.lternet.edu/listinfo/bioprod -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From w.cheung at oceans.ubc.ca Tue Mar 30 08:34:40 2021 From: w.cheung at oceans.ubc.ca (Cheung, William) Date: Tue, 30 Mar 2021 15:34:40 +0000 Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update In-Reply-To: References: <707123EE-7CB5-49A4-8C46-38D995F98C68@zoology.ubc.ca> <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> Message-ID: <7D175123-68CD-4AE4-AF47-385C61362BA7@mail.ubc.ca> Thank you very much Mary! Fingers crossed. Cheers, William On Mar 30, 2021, at 8:20 AM, Andrew Gonzalez, Prof. > wrote: [CAUTION: Non-UBC Email] Hurrah! How great that PRSB will review it, Mary. Thank you for getting us to this point. Fingers crossed for smooth review! Andy ________________________________ From: Bioprod > on behalf of Mary O'Connor > Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2021 11:06 AM To: Forest Isbell > Cc: William Cheung >; Michel Loreau >; bioprod at lternet.edu > Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update Hello everyone, Thanks for the feedback by the end of Feb, as requested! It took me a couple weeks to get it all wrapped up, and then I submitted our pre-submission request to PRSB, as required by the journal. The Reviews editor was way for a few weeks, hence the delay. I just heard back that we can submit our review, so I will do that today or tomorrow. That’s the update! So now, figures crossed and I’ll send around the submitted version when I’m done. Best, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com On Feb 10, 2021, at 10:36 AM, Mary O'Connor > wrote: Dear all, I hope you and yours are doing all right. I’m writing with the "Agenda paper", ready to submit and just need your final ‘OK’ or any minor feedback! Update: As you know, this has proceeded in fits and starts over the last few years. I thought we were done in summer 2019, but a few good points were raised around that time that required a bit more work on my part, and here we are. Last summer (2020) I presented this at ESA and around that time, got good and careful comments and contributions on the MS from our core writing team (Forest, Akira, Laura, Andy G). I have incorporated all those comments, and have also updated the manuscript a little bit since our original drafting (3 years ago!). I hope you like it! I’d like to submit it by the end of Feb to Proceedings of the Royal Society. Right now I’m simply asking for your ‘ok’. If there are revisions needed that can wait till we get reviews, I will happily take them and file them for that time; if things need to be done before we submit, I will do my best!. The ms hasn’t changed much since summer so if your read it then you have a good idea of where it is. If you haven’t read it in a few years, I suggest you do take a quick look. Finally, you will see that William Cheung has joined us as a co-author and on this email. William is a colleague at UBC and has been a contributor and co-author on the IBPES modelling scenarios and the scenarios chapter to which we refer in this paper, so I’m very grateful he has joined us and provided his comments on the ms as well. Action items (in summary): 1. Please confirm that you’re ok for me to submit this to PRSB 2. Please send me your address or add it in a comment in the ms. 3. OPTIONAL: help with figures if you are inspired 4. OPTIONAL: minor edits for pre-submission, major edits for post-review 5. OPTIONAL: Box 3 needs a little work, I think, and I wonder if one of you who originally drafted it could finalize it? A few loose ends on the figures remain to be tied up, which I will do while you review. If you have time AND see opportunities to improve figures, I welcome that help at this stage! (There were some issues I couldn’t resolve with the figures we had before, but if you miss them and would like help revise, we can discuss how to do that; it is possible). Best wishes, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com _______________________________________________ Bioprod mailing list Bioprod at lists.lternet.edu https://lists.lternet.edu/listinfo/bioprod -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: From Jarrett.Byrnes at umb.edu Tue Mar 30 08:59:37 2021 From: Jarrett.Byrnes at umb.edu (Jarrett Byrnes) Date: Tue, 30 Mar 2021 15:59:37 +0000 Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update In-Reply-To: <7D175123-68CD-4AE4-AF47-385C61362BA7@mail.ubc.ca> References: <707123EE-7CB5-49A4-8C46-38D995F98C68@zoology.ubc.ca> <5B782BE6-5AE8-4D1D-BEB5-ED2BC7AF5F7B@zoology.ubc.ca> <7D175123-68CD-4AE4-AF47-385C61362BA7@mail.ubc.ca> Message-ID: <3640573d-6ef1-4d87-9655-30b4b07a2722@Spark> Wahoo! Fingers crossed! So excited to see this feedback framework getting out there! -Jarrett Byrnes ------------- Jarrett Byrnes Associate Professor Dept. of Biology UMass Boston 401-529-4104 pronouns: he, him, his http://byrneslab.net @jebyrnes On Mar 30, 2021, 11:39 AM -0400, Cheung, William , wrote: EXTERNAL SENDER Thank you very much Mary! Fingers crossed. Cheers, William On Mar 30, 2021, at 8:20 AM, Andrew Gonzalez, Prof. > wrote: [CAUTION: Non-UBC Email] Hurrah! How great that PRSB will review it, Mary. Thank you for getting us to this point. Fingers crossed for smooth review! Andy ________________________________ From: Bioprod > on behalf of Mary O'Connor > Sent: Tuesday, March 30, 2021 11:06 AM To: Forest Isbell > Cc: William Cheung >; Michel Loreau >; bioprod at lternet.edu > Subject: [LTER-BioProd] Biodiversity Grand Challenges paper - update Hello everyone, Thanks for the feedback by the end of Feb, as requested! It took me a couple weeks to get it all wrapped up, and then I submitted our pre-submission request to PRSB, as required by the journal. The Reviews editor was way for a few weeks, hence the delay. I just heard back that we can submit our review, so I will do that today or tomorrow. That’s the update! So now, figures crossed and I’ll send around the submitted version when I’m done. Best, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com On Feb 10, 2021, at 10:36 AM, Mary O'Connor > wrote: Dear all, I hope you and yours are doing all right. I’m writing with the "Agenda paper", ready to submit and just need your final ‘OK’ or any minor feedback! Update: As you know, this has proceeded in fits and starts over the last few years. I thought we were done in summer 2019, but a few good points were raised around that time that required a bit more work on my part, and here we are. Last summer (2020) I presented this at ESA and around that time, got good and careful comments and contributions on the MS from our core writing team (Forest, Akira, Laura, Andy G). I have incorporated all those comments, and have also updated the manuscript a little bit since our original drafting (3 years ago!). I hope you like it! I’d like to submit it by the end of Feb to Proceedings of the Royal Society. Right now I’m simply asking for your ‘ok’. If there are revisions needed that can wait till we get reviews, I will happily take them and file them for that time; if things need to be done before we submit, I will do my best!. The ms hasn’t changed much since summer so if your read it then you have a good idea of where it is. If you haven’t read it in a few years, I suggest you do take a quick look. Finally, you will see that William Cheung has joined us as a co-author and on this email. William is a colleague at UBC and has been a contributor and co-author on the IBPES modelling scenarios and the scenarios chapter to which we refer in this paper, so I’m very grateful he has joined us and provided his comments on the ms as well. Action items (in summary): 1. Please confirm that you’re ok for me to submit this to PRSB 2. Please send me your address or add it in a comment in the ms. 3. OPTIONAL: help with figures if you are inspired 4. OPTIONAL: minor edits for pre-submission, major edits for post-review 5. OPTIONAL: Box 3 needs a little work, I think, and I wonder if one of you who originally drafted it could finalize it? A few loose ends on the figures remain to be tied up, which I will do while you review. If you have time AND see opportunities to improve figures, I welcome that help at this stage! (There were some issues I couldn’t resolve with the figures we had before, but if you miss them and would like help revise, we can discuss how to do that; it is possible). Best wishes, Mary ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Dr. Mary O'Connor Associate Professor, Department of Zoology Associate Director, Biodiversity Research Centre University of British Columbia ph: 604-827-5653 oconnor at zoology.ubc.ca oconnorlab.weebly.com _______________________________________________ Bioprod mailing list Bioprod at lists.lternet.edu https://lists.lternet.edu/listinfo/bioprod -------------- next part -------------- An HTML attachment was scrubbed... URL: